       ![Elizabeth Rovere and Brian O'Kelley smiling at the camera](/sites/g/files/omnuum5526/files/styles/hwp_21_9__1920x825/public/2026-11/Rovere-OKelley_0.jpg?itok=dL-lY9TM) 

 



 

#  Beyond Certainty: Wonder, Wisdom, and the Expansiveness of Humility 

 





Elizabeth Rovere, MTS ’95, and Brian O’Kelley share their perspectives on contemplative thinking, ethical action, and the importance of the humanities.



 

October 30, 2026

 

 

 [ Suzannah Lutz ](/people/suzannah-lutz) 

Elizabeth Rovere, MTS ’95, remembers experiencing a deep curiosity from an early age. “In Sunday school, I was seen as a troublemaker, asking how Adam and Eve fit with dinosaurs and evolution,” says Rovere. “I was perplexed at why people spoke with such certainty, glossed over contradictions, and pushed away my questions.” It was Rovere’s grandmother who encouraged this natural curiosity. “She was a devout Catholic,” says Rovere, “but also fantastically irreverent. She loved the twists and turns of biblical parables and the wisdom she found in them. She showed me that faith and questioning did not have to be in opposition.”

Today, as a clinical psychologist, host of the podcast *Wonderstruck*, and member of the HDS Dean’s Council, Rovere continues to explore what she describes as “the edges of what we know.” Her husband, Brian O’Kelley, has spent his career in technology, recently working to decarbonize online advertising. In this Q&amp;A, Rovere and O’Kelley offer their insights on the importance of contemplative thinking, ethical action, and the humanities.

## What led you to Harvard Divinity School?

**Rovere:** As an undergraduate, I studied Russian literature, including Tolstoy and Dostoevsky, which became an avenue into deeper questions of spirituality, psychology, and meaning. The pivotal point for me was when my father died. I was devastated, and I didn’t know how to live with my grief. I knew I needed something beyond the intellectual and material. That search eventually led me to HDS.

The philosopher and psychologist, William James, was important to me because he took religious experience seriously. HDS became a place where I could look at the great mysteries of life without rigid doctrines. It was intellectually rigorous while leaving room for the unknown and experiential ways of knowing. I also had a wonderful professor of ethics, Arthur Dyck, who didn’t simply teach compassion and goodness—he embodied them. He emanated a sense of virtue that was palpable. Meeting and learning from him, and others in the HDS community who live out their values in that way, has been incredibly meaningful.

## Your podcast, *Wonderstruck*, explores the edges of what we can explain. What can we learn from being open to awe and wonder?

**Rovere:** Awe is such an extraordinary word because it holds apparent opposites inside it. Something can be awful and awesome, terrifying and terrific, like an earth-shaking thunderstorm, a sunset that brings you to tears, or Moses, in fear and amazement, utterly shattered by his encounter with the burning bush. You are face-to-face with something almost beyond your capacity to bear. Wonder, to me, is what happens at the horizon of what we know.

We think certainty gives us security, yet it can offer false security when it requires us to pretend there is no mystery. We can’t mistake what we choose to pay attention to for the limits of what there is or may be. Sometimes something breaks through that boundary, a profound or so-called anomalous experience, grief, even love, and it doesn’t fit our existing framework. Our sense of what is real and possible can shift.

Wonder asks us to stand at that horizon without immediately retreating to what we already know. That requires humility. And I don’t mean humiliation. Humility doesn’t make us smaller. It loosens our grip on the idea that our model of reality is reality itself and leaves us open to mystery, to other people, to nature, to something larger than ourselves. In that sense, I think wonder can save us from ourselves.





 

 

 

   

Our world is accelerating at a rate we can barely comprehend. This is not the time to relegate the humanities, especially the study of spirituality and religion.

 

Elizabeth Rovere

MTS ’95

 

 



 

 

 

## What drew the two of you to supporting the Transcendence and Transformation initiative at the Center for the Study of World Religions?

**Rovere:** The Center has become incredibly important to me. Under Charles Stang’s leadership, the Center takes questions of mysticism, contemplation, transcendence, consciousness, and transformation seriously. The Center’s work on transcendentalism also converges with what we’re exploring through *Wonderstruck*, such as nature, direct experience, consciousness, the sacred, and ways of knowing that cannot be reduced to doctrine or text.

**O’Kelley:** We host an annual dinner connected to the Center’s Transcendence and Transformation initiative, and the work continues questions that scholars like William James were asking more than a century ago: How do we understand profound experiences that transform people’s understanding of themselves and the world without dismissing them simply because we can’t explain them?

**Rovere:** We need the capacity to analyze, but we also need the capacity to contemplate and remain open to mystery. You can’t just float around in a big question, but you also can’t narrow the world down to the minutiae and mistake the part for the whole. Our world is accelerating at a rate we can barely comprehend. This is not the time to relegate the humanities, especially the study of spirituality and religion. This is the time for contemplative thinking to be in full bloom, to ask: What does it mean? How is it possible? What is it for? What kind of beings are we becoming?

**O’Kelley:** As an entrepreneur, these questions are especially important. Technology gives us tremendous capacity to build things, but the fact that we can build something doesn’t tell us whether we should. What is right? What is good? Who does it serve? What is the purpose of what we’re doing beyond money?

## What inspires you most about HDS and your support for the HDS Fund?

**Rovere:** There is a real sense of community at HDS. Dean Marla Frederick is an exceptional leader. I particularly appreciate her interest, as an anthropologist, in religion as something lived in people’s homes, communities, and public lives—not simply something studied from a distance.

The great Sufi mystic Ibn Arabi understood remembrance as an awakening to something already within us, a remembering of our relationship to the divine. Mother Teresa said that if we have no peace, it is because “we have forgotten that we belong to each other.” I think those ideas are deeply connected. Wonder can be an act of remembering the sacred, remembering that we belong to one another, that we belong to nature, and that we participate in something larger than ourselves. Maybe the task isn’t only to discover something new beyond the horizon. Maybe it is also to remember what, somewhere along the way, we learned not to see.

In supporting the students, faculty, and work of Harvard Divinity School, the HDS Fund makes room for this kind of inquiry to flourish: questions of spirit, consciousness, meaning, suffering, virtue, and connection. These questions aren’t luxuries; they are among our oldest human curiosities, and they bring us together through shared experiences of wonder and awe.





 

### Dean's Report 

 

Learn more out about Harvard Divinity School’s recent research, teaching, and impact.



 [Read the Report chevron\_right](/deans-report) 

 



      ![HDS Dean's Report 2026](/sites/g/files/omnuum5526/files/styles/hwp_1_1__480x480/public/2026-11/DeansReport2026_cover.jpg?h=d35f4b21&itok=4wFMTqge)