Interconnectedness and Insightful Scholarship
In conversation with author, beekeeper, and sustainable investing expert Katherine Collins, MTS ’11
Katherine Collins, MTS ’11, is the founder of Honeybee Capital, an author focused on financial and spiritual best practices, and a beekeeper. Last year, she retired from her role as the head of sustainable investing at Putnam Investments and has since become chair of the HDS Dean’s Council. “Harvard Divinity School is in a leading position to develop and amplify voices that carry foundational, root-level wisdom with deep intellectual and spiritual integrity,” says Collins. In a recent interview, she shared more about her multifaceted background and her belief in the power of multireligious education.
What would you like to share about your background and what led you to HDS as a student?
For the entirety of my 35-year career, I’ve worked as an investor; I started right out of college. Unlike many parts of finance these days, the investment work I’ve done has always been directly connected to the world in which we live, looking at real companies that make real products we can see all around us. It’s the only part of investing that interests me—the way finance dovetails with the world we get to inhabit.
At a certain point in my practice, I noticed that a growing number of corporate leadership teams were wrestling with fundamental sustainability issues, though they might not have used that descriptor. At their essence, the questions revolved around individual versus collective good, or short-term versus long-term impact, or equity and power imbalances. At the same time, sustainability practices within the business world were developing in very tactical ways, focusing not so much on these foundational questions but on more easily quantifiable operational elements. I wanted to become more fluent in the issues at hand so that I could create a coherent, holistic investment strategy that did not reduce such vital questions into overly simplistic metrics or scorecards. HDS emerged as the perfect place to explore the collective wisdom that has already been developed regarding these deeper issues, while bringing together its theoretical and practical applications.
How has the study of religion guided your personal and professional callings?
There are two threads that are equally important. The first is more intellectually oriented—the idea that, within an inhabited set of living systems, things are already connected. The actions of any one part of the system affect the whole system in this interconnected, constantly evolving, iterative world. This carries ethical implications; what we do matters. Thankfully, we have deeply rooted philosophical, ethical, and religious frameworks to guide our decisions.
The beauty of this, especially in investing, is it provides a longer-duration counterweight to processes that otherwise often center on immediate outcomes. The other thread that I developed at HDS has a more human dimension, recognizing that a sense of ministry can be relevant in all sorts of professional settings. Specifically, my time at HDS heightened my awareness that whatever we do is in service of something or someone, and that effective ministry is a skill; it is possible to learn and improve.
Both of these threads are somewhat alien within many financial settings, where it’s tempting to believe that narrowly defined mathematics alone can lead to good decision-making. But the inputs to those equations are almost all determined by humans and the broader systems that we inhabit and influence. Why not connect the dots?
Specifically, my time at HDS heightened my awareness that whatever we do is in service of something or someone, and that effective ministry is a skill; it is possible to learn and improve."
Your two books, The Nature of Investing and Month of Sundays, seem to be vastly different—the first focused on finance and the second on faith. What inspired you to write them, and are there surprising similarities throughout?
During my time at HDS, I consistently found clarity through the writing process. To me, my two books serve a deceptively similar purpose. They both begin with the premise that we’re living in a nested arrangement of complex adaptive systems that are constantly evolving. Both books recognize that there are conditions, in life and in investing, over which we are not in control, and yet we still have agency. Given that reality, my writing explores ways that we can be appropriately responsive, instead of guarded or reckless. My hope is that the books illustrate the root systems that we can hold on to when the wind is blowing.
Both volumes reflect insights that originally developed during my studies at HDS, and my related contemplative practices. The Nature of Investing focuses on the natural world’s structure and function, and how it provides the blueprint for healthy, regenerative systems in business and investment settings. Month of Sundays is a more personal set of reflections on the natural, spiritual, and human resources that support us. In both cases, I aim to explore deceptively simple questions of our ever-changing world: What is newly visible? What is newly valuable? What is newly possible?
With the MRPL degree program and expanded course offerings, the study of religion and public life has grown significantly at HDS in recent years. What has changed since your time as an MTS student, and what hopes do you have for the study of religion in the years ahead?
One reason I chose HDS is that it opened up the potential for me to study horizontally, as opposed to declaring a more vertical religious tradition as my primary focus. That was still a relatively new development when I first began my studies in 2009. There weren’t many places that offered this possibility—and the School has been leading this effort by becoming even more multifaith, multidimensional, and multivocational over the years. Pedagogically, this depth and breadth supports the development of insights and skills that are sorely needed in our world today.
Dean Frederick recently asked you to lead the Dean’s Council at HDS. What do you find most exciting about this new role?
I recently retired from my corporate role within the investment world and have given myself time to discern what this new chapter will become. That said, when asked to lead the Dean’s Council, I accepted with great enthusiasm. One area of focus for me is to illuminate the ways in which HDS can uniquely contribute to the most pressing issues of our time. Speaking broadly, many of the discussions about these issues live on the surface, while what’s needed is more foundational, root-level wisdom with deep intellectual and spiritual integrity. To get practical, when I look at our strategic plan, I’m excited that the first pillar is focused on scholarly excellence. Everything that follows rests on the unique, insightful scholarship led by community members connected to Harvard Divinity School.
Seasons of Discernment
Since retiring from the investment industry, Katherine Collins has devoted the first year of this new chapter to discerning where she would like to dedicate her time and energy—inspired by nature and the changing seasons.
Winter
Focus on rest and foundational practices, including meditation and writing
Spring
Focus on exploration and reflection, including a poetry workshop on the island of Iona, Scotland, and a pilgrimage walk of the Kumano Kodo route in Japan
Summer
Focus on connections to nature, including hiking part of the John Muir Trail in California and tending honeybees in the Berkshire Hills of Massachusetts
Fall
Focus on community and service, including chairing the HDS Dean’s Council