Meaning Makers of HDS: Reporting on Religion in America
In this episode of Meaning Makers of HDS, AP reporter Tiffany Stanley, MDiv ’10, and RNS reporter Jack Jenkins, MDiv ’12, speak about their work covering religion and politics in America.
Produced by the Harvard Divinity School Office of Communications, Meaning Makers of HDS explores the many dimensions of human meaning making. In interviews with HDS alumni, faculty, and others, this podcast showcases how members of the HDS community create meaningful lives—through religion, spirituality, faith, and beyond. Each episode features conversations that highlight the deeply personal and diverse ways people wrestle with life’s biggest questions.
In the third episode of Meaning Makers of HDS, we spoke with Associated Press reporter Tiffany Stanley, MDiv ’10, and Religion News Service reporter Jack Jenkins, MDiv ’12. Throughout the conversation, Stanley and Jenkins spoke about their work covering religion in America, how religious discourse shaped the recent midterm elections, and the importance of a people-centered journalistic ethics.
Jack Jenkins, MDiv '12
Jack Jenkins, MDiv '12, is an award-winning journalist and national reporter for the Religion News Service (RNS), where he covers religion and politics. He's also the author of the book American Prophets: The Religious Roots of Progressive Politics and the Ongoing Fight for the Soul of the Country, published by HarperOne. In addition to serving as senior religion reporter at ThinkProgress for more than three years before starting at RNS, his stories and analyses from all over the globe have been published in the Washington Post, NPR, Rolling Stone, Atlantic, Associated Press, Daily Beast, National Catholic Reporter, and others. His work has also been cited or featured in the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, New Yorker, CNN, MSNBC, a Netflix docu-series, and the "God and Country" documentary on Christian nationalism, among others.
"I think being a witness in this work is a profound responsibility and privilege and should be taken as such. Because if done poorly, it can have negative impacts on the people who have given you that trust to begin with."
Tiffany Stanley, MDiv '10
Tiffany Stanley, MDiv '10, is an editor and reporter with the global religion team at the Associated Press. She has also written for The Washington Post, The New Republic, The Atlantic, Politico, Religion News Service, and more. Her work has been a finalist for a National Magazine Award, anthologized in The Best American Magazine Writing, and honored with top honors from the Religion News Association. Before working for the AP, she helped create Religion & Politics, now known as Arc, an award-winning online journal at Washington University in St. Louis.
"I took a lot away from HDS in terms of pastoral care and how to be with people in really hard moments. I interned for a year as a hospital chaplain and did all these things that HDS allowed me to do. I've taken a lot of those lessons of how to listen empathically. I try to reflect back what people are telling me so I'm getting it right."
TYLER SPROUSE: Welcome to Meaning Makers of HDS, a podcast by Harvard Divinity School exploring meaning making through religion, spirituality, vocation, and beyond. Each episode of this podcast features HDS alumni and other community members discussing how they cultivate meaningful lives, working across an array of fields, and how they help others do the same. In this episode, I spoke with Associated Press reporter Tiffany Stanley, MDiv ’10, and Religion News Service reporter Jack Jenkins, MDiv ’12, about their work covering religion in America, how religious discourse shaped the recent midterm elections, and the importance of a people-centered journalistic ethics. I'm Tyler Sprouse, and this is Meaning Makers of HDS.
Tiffany and Jack, thank you so much for joining me in conversation today for our third episode of The Meaning Makers of HTS. I'm super excited to talk with you both about journalism, spirituality, meaning-making. Just to begin, could you introduce yourselves and talk a little bit about your work as journalists? Maybe the beats that you currently cover, and what interests you most in the work?
TIFFANY STANLEY: I'm Tiffany Stanley, and I am a reporter and editor on the Global Religion Team at the Associated Press. And I would say our portfolio really runs the gamut. The great thing about the religion beat is it intersects with almost every other desk at our news organization. So I just wrote a sports story. I've been writing a lot of politics stories. I've written health stories this year. So that's one of the things I love the most about it, is the secret is that you get to do a lot of different kinds of reporting while also reporting on religion. But I would say my specialty is probably religion and public life or religion and politics, which I know is a specialty of Jack's as well.
JACK JENKINS: I'm Jack Jenkins. I am a national reporter with Religion News Service, which has a partnership with the Associated Press and their religion team. And we also cover the gamut of religion, but I specialize in religion and politics, which means the last couple of weeks have been very busy for me amid the midterms and what have you. But I've been basically covering that for since at least 2014 full time. And then there was a span in which I covered religion and politics and Catholicism for a while for about six years. And admittedly, many of those Catholicism stories were also religion and politics stories. But now, these days, I am chasing down a bishop or a senator on any given day.
SPROUSE: Can you talk about your journey into this field and maybe share also how your time at HDS and the study of religion generally shape you as journalists?
STANLEY: I came to HDS already as a journalist, but I was a young journalist. I've known since high school that I wanted to be-- or maybe even before that, a writer. I've always wanted to be a writer. And I fell in love with student journalism in high school, did that in college, and came out thinking, OK, I'm going to do this. But do I have a beat? What do I want to write about? And I found my way to HDS, as everybody probably does, through a circuitous path.
But the thing that stood out to me is I did really want to write about religion. I also was exploring other callings as a person of faith myself. But I thought, it couldn't hurt to have more academic knowledge of this. At the time when I was heading to HDS, we were coming out of the George W. Bush presidential administration and heading into the Obama administration. There was a lot talk about faith and politics and things like that in the national conversation. And I thought, well, I can use my time here to explore my own path, but also other people's. And I see a need here and I see that there are other journalists like doing this really well. And that's what I want to do. And so the fact I get to do that now is amazing. And times when this job is tough, it helps to remember, hey, this is your dream. You have always wanted to do this. So it really is a dream job. And it's what I've always wanted to do.
JENKINS: I'm glad Tiffany went first, because it's also partially her fault that I'm a journalist. So the reality is, I came into Divinity School with exactly zero experience in journalism and zero academic background in it. And then but someone had pioneered interning for Religion News Service while at Harvard Divinity School, and that was Tiffany Stanley. Following her the next year was a buddy of mine, Alfredo Garcia Mora. I was technically an ordination track at HDS. It was tentative. And then there was a minor schism in my denomination. And so those of us who were under care are in the process, actually got frozen for a spell while people figured out if they wanted to stay. The people who were in charge of us stayed if they wanted to stay in the denomination or not.
So a summer that I was going to spend doing ordination stuff, I suddenly had free. And he suggested that I consider an internship at Religion News Service. The editor-in-chief of Religion News Service at the time, Kevin Ekstrom, actually came and spoke at HDS. And I somehow convinced him to let me intern. And the rest was history. Basically, they hired me on contract for my third year when I was at HDS. And then I continued to write, even coming out of grad school. I worked for another publication for a while. And then eventually got poached back to RNS in 2018. But if Tiffany had not braved the RNS internship path, then I may not actually have ever been a reporter. So I'm very grateful for her trailblazing there.
SPROUSE: Let's stay on that connection between the study of religion, which you both explored here at HDS, and the practice of journalism. For folks who may be less aware that there is a thriving religion beat within the field, can you talk about how you understand the relationship? And then I'm also curious, just based on what you've just talked about, for current students or incoming students who may have an interest in writing or they really enjoy journalism but aren't sure how to break into the field given this area of academic study, what might you say to those students?
STANLEY: : I always tell young journalists that I talk to-- or really any journalists, it doesn't matter where you are at-- is that you don't need a graduate education to do this work, and you should not go into debt to do that, because journalism is not a lucrative field, but ministry. So I try to make sure that people know that this is not something you have to do. And I would say that to people about considering a graduate degree in journalism as well. But I also know it can be a great opportunity for networking to do more internships, like Jack was just saying, to give yourself a little bit more time.
I did not come from a family where a lot of people went to college. My mom graduated from college when I was in kindergarten, my dad didn't go. So how to navigate getting your foot in the door in a professional sense. I was a bit of a late bloomer. I just did not how to do some of these things. And I think graduate school gave me extra time to figure out how to do those things and gave me extra space to be immersed in a liberal arts education and read and write deeply and do all these things that I love. So I have never once regretted my degree at all. 100% worth it. But I want to caution people that you can be a journalist without that. And I know so many journalists who, they learned on the job, they're a specific beat. Or they've jumped around different beats and they just immersed themselves in it. So it's not a requirement, but it can be amazing.
And I think the internships and the portfolio of what we call clips, your stories, or whether it's an audio form, TV form, written form, those form the bulk of your resume when you're applying for journalism jobs. So I always encourage people that even if you feel uncertain, you can always freelance. You do not have to be on staff to write for a lot of publications. In fact, given the nature of our business, sometimes a lot of publications depend on freelancers. If you're in a graduate program, that gives you this expertise that you should own and go out there. Write for people, pitch people, email people. A lot of people are going to want to help you out in a way that I think people sometimes feel afraid. So I think that it can give you that space.
I met a lot of sources as a graduate student. Now I know a lot of scholars. I feel like I have this weird superpower sometimes with reporters I work with because they're like, oh, I need to write about this thing. Do you know an expert? And I'm like, here's this person who wrote this book on ancient Christianity and the Greco-Roman world. I don't know, whatever it is. There's things in my brain that I can pull out and be like, here's somebody that writes about religion and politics really well, here's somebody that does this really well, here's somebody that writes about the Black church or about American Islam. And I think that's great, too. Always learning, always growing and doing that.
JENKINS: It may not surprise you to know that Tiffany and I's philosophy here is very similar. I am also of the persuasion that you don't need any background or academic background in journalism to be a good journalist. I think being a good journalist is an aggressively human thing about connections, about people. About writing, absolutely. But the specific academic training, I do not think it's required. I also am of the persuasion that a good reporter can cover anything. That doesn't mean you're going to cover it as well as someone who is actually a beat expert. But a good reporter, you can be dropped into a new world and figure it out as quickly as you can to do something adequate, right.
That's one of the skill sets that I think is often most important for reporting, is being able to become some degree of expert pretty quickly. And that is rooted in the knowing what you don't know impulse, right. Wanting to ask a question as opposed to pronounce what you already believe. That having been said, I will say one of the great things about studying religion is that there's a lot of engagement with other human beings in that process. And for me, it's the study of human communities, human cultures, and their interaction, of course, with the divine. But for Tiffany's point, going to HDS as a religion reporter, that proved to be very beneficial, not only for the academic study of religion, but honestly, just the broad range of faiths and people that I got to know while I was there is frankly equally, if not more important than the stuff I did in the classroom. That particularly for the pursuit of journalism.
But that inherent curiosity that a religion degree often requires of its students, I think, is a similar impulse that reporters use. And I will say now, being a religion reporter, I think I probably use my degree every day and constantly, aggressively. But again, I do not think that is required. And I've actually seen people do great religion journalism who have no background in it. If you're willing to take the content and the communities seriously.
SPROUSE: I'd love to get your perspectives on the current state of journalism. What are your impressions of the field right now? What has been your experience? There's a lot talk about the shifting and the changing landscape. What are some challenges you face currently as working journalists, and where do you see opportunities?
JENKINS: How long is this podcast, by the way?
[LAUGHTER]
SPROUSE: As long as we need it to be.
JENKINS: I'll go. I'll leap in just real quick, because I actually want to hear what Tiffany has to say. I will say, the challenges are obvious. There's a journalism economics issue. I have a lot. By virtue of being a religion and politics reporter, you engage with a lot of political reporters from other outlets. And it's wild to see friends who are fantastic world class reporters just get laid off, right. I spent time on Capitol Hill and the Capitol Hill press corps, and you just see people who don't show up anymore. And they belong to an outlet with way more money than mine does, for instance. And these layoffs are happening across sectors.
And what people read and how they read it is a constant challenge. Even now, I'm producing vertical videos like everyone else now, which actually are fun and a fascinating form of journalism. I am also producing a written story usually alongside that. So doing both. But one thing I think you'll notice is that a lot of outlets that are doing everything at once right now, because it isn't guaranteed that you would find a specific audience in one location. And so there's a lot in anxiety and uncertainty about what comes next. That having been said, I do think there is a profound amount of fantastic journalism still happening.
And while nonprofit journalism-- and I write for a nonprofit outlet. While it is not exempt from these journalistic trends, it is weirdly in at least a slightly better position than many of forprofit sectors. Mostly because these outlets aren't designed to make money, by definition. And so it's been interesting to see some nonprofit outlets begin to thrive in the midst of all this. One prominent example is the Baltimore Banner, right. And similar entities that have that either started as nonprofits or ended up nonprofits. So that's something to keep an eye on as well. But it's something I tell when I talk to young journalists these days and they're asking me about, how did you get to where you are? Through a pathway that doesn't exist anymore. Right, there's an entire avenue of journalism that I came through that, frankly, isn't replicable now. And so the skill sets that young journalists are learning are different, frankly, than what I was learning even 10 or 15 years ago. So but I'm real curious to hear what Tiffany has to say about the same subject.
STANLEY: Yeah, I would just echo what Jack said. I mean, it's a rough timeout here. And this speed at which AI is changing search traffic and how we get audiences in. It's so much more rapid than I think I was ever prepared for. So AP has gone through our own buyouts and layoffs the past couple years, and it's been really hard. And I am encouraged that there are a lot of people that are very smart that are trying to come up with ways to fund our notforprofit news cooperative and how that's going to work. But I think there is-- like Jack was saying, there's a lot of uncertainty of how that's going to work. What new thing will let us sustain our business models?
And I am encouraged by the nonprofit funding model. By donors, by things where you see people saying, we want to support this because journalism is a public good and we think it's a good idea. And I know at AP, we're doing a lot of work around, how do we support local news outlets that used to be our customers and they're all dwindling? And local news is so important. And the information that they provide. And we have all these so-called news deserts. So I do not have any solutions, but I am in awe of the people that are rapidly trying to figure it out. And I'm trying to be a team player, and they want to put us on video and they want us to do this and they want us to do that.
And whatever lets us still do the work and tell the stories that we need to tell and I'm game for. But it's a tough time. And it's the economic situation I think nationally is also affecting it. But technological change is hard. It's just really hard, and we've got to figure it out.
SPROUSE: We’re holding this conversation one week after the midterm elections. As we saw, questions around and debates about faith were critical in this election cycle. Can you talk about what stood out to you in terms of how religious discourse shaped this election?
STANLEY: Man, there's so much to say. I mean, this has been a very exciting midterms for those of us that talk about religion all the time and that we see it in politics all the time, but it is like everyone saw it this time. And we have, on both sides of the aisle, people with Divinity School seminary backgrounds who won elections. And I think in America, we've always had Black clergy that talk about faith and politics in a way that they're very comfortable with it. And Black Protestants vote overwhelmingly Democratic, so that's been one piece of a story for a while.
But there's always been this question of the religious left, which I'm excited to hear Jack's take, since he wrote a book about the religious left. But there's always been this idea of, there's a lot of progressive, mainline Christians who maybe don't talk as fluently about that. And so in this election, we got to see four of those clergy or seminary student nicknames, in the case of James Talarico, be elected in somewhat unexpected places, like Kansas, where it had been almost a century since they had a Democratic senator. And now they have a United Methodist pastor as their senator.
And then on top of that, outside the Christian world, we have the first Muslim senator from Michigan, Abdullah Al Sayed. And in that, it's something that I know RNS and AP are covering a lot is the rise in Islamophobia, anti-Semitism, how those get talked about in politics. So there's all these threads that have culminated this year that have given us a lot of fodder, have given my politics colleagues a lot of fodder. I don't know if the US is unique worldwide in how we talk about religion and politics, but we certainly-- it's there, and it's always in the room. And it's something that I think no matter what you cover as a journalist, you have to be able to have an ear to hear that religious language in our public life. I think it's always a helpful skill to have.
JENKINS: Yeah, hard agree. I mean, I appreciate Tiffany saying she wants to listen to my take. But one thing that I've said about Tiffany before is that she's the most obnoxious kind of journalist. And but I mean that as a compliment, because she is an editor, which we reporters like to think of as distant from us. But she's an editor who then will go write a story better than you could ever write it. So she is one of the best at both worlds. And I say that as having been edited by Tiffany as well.
But I do think what's been fascinating about this midterms moment is that two things are true. It is absolutely the case that Democrats have used religious language throughout American history, just as Republicans have. And a lot of times, that goes unacknowledged. Right, a classic example I often list is when Nancy Pelosi was giving her speech announcing that she was no longer going to pursue party leadership. A whole section of that speech was her talking about her Catholic faith. Which anybody who's covered Nancy Pelosi knows she does all the time. But if you read a lot of the more hard and political reports on that speech, it was like they just cut that whole section out, right.
So there is this case to be made that not only among Black Protestants, but among Democrats in general, you actually have a lot of religious rhetoric that has gone unignored-- I mean, gone ignored for many years. That has now, because it was so faith forward, this midterm election, because it was candidates who were literally clergy. Or in the case of Talarico giving victory speech in front of a podium with a placard on it that said, love thy neighbor. It became very difficult to ignore, right? On the other hand, it also is the graduation of that rhetoric from something that also happens to the center of some Democratic political rhetoric. And what I mean by that is can trace this long tail of what happened last Tuesday, back to when Trump-- you can trace it all the way back throughout American history to the Civil Rights movement, what have you.
But in a more contemporary sense, you can see the protests and within faith communities that emerged after Trump's first election back in 2016, both among Black Protestants, but also among liberal mainliners and also many of the interfaith colleagues that they-- and partnerships that those entities built with each other. A lot of that rhetoric has been very present in protests, right. Often directly decrying and critiquing conservative Christians in particular. Right, and the positions of those conservative Christians in politics. And so it was fascinating to see that shift from protests that I had seen, covered in 2016, 2017, what have you, to some of those folks running for office. So, for instance, two of the clergy members that were elected on Tuesday, Reverend Sarah Trone Garriott and Reverend Lindsey James, were actually already state lawmakers in Iowa. And Lindsey James actually had to beat out a Methodist minister in order to become the Democratic nominee in her race in that state.
And then of course, now they're running for Congress. So you see that train. And then this whole wave is following Raphael Warnock. While it is certainly not the case that Black Protestants with clergy or ministerial real credentials are new in Congress-- in fact, there was a whole wave in the '80s people forget about. And there was also a couple of Catholic priests that got elected at that time that people also forget about, because the Pope had to step in and tell them they could no longer be elected officials. But Warnock brought this gravitas to it that it became this tension even this year, where there was a whole fight over the interpretation of Matthew 25 in Congress.
And so what I think is really fascinating about this moment is, it's not that the rhetoric is necessarily new or the arguments are necessarily new. Theologically speaking, within Christianity or even within Islam in terms of what that looks like in American politics. But the graduation from protest level or demonstration level to walking through the halls of Congress. There were images this week of Reverend Adam Hamilton, the Methodist mega pastor out of Kansas, walking alongside newly elected Michigan senator Abdul El-Sayed. And then laughing and joking together. And that, I think, is jarring to some Americans, but it's actually like perfectly in keeping with some of the demonstrations and communities I've seen protests together over the last 10 years. So it's an interesting transition moment in that regard.
SPROUSE: In light of what you’ve both just shared, I’m curious about your views of the future. When thinking about younger generations and religion in America, in light of these midterm results, do you see things shifting? Jack, you just distinguished between established rhetoric versus a changing dynamic. Could you both talk about how things might look moving forward?
JENKINS: I'm curious what Tiffany have to say about this, too, because there's a whole discourse about whether or not there's actually a religious revival happening among young people or not. And my colleagues have written about that, and I know folks at AP have as well. I will say a couple different dynamics. One, that the religious unaffiliation or disaffiliation. Right, the growth of the religiously unaffiliated. The nones in NES is across the board among all religious groups in the United States. It's happening to some more than others, right. There is also a growth of religiously unaffiliated, for instance, among Black Protestants. But it is less than we have seen over the course of white Christians over the last 20 years.
And so it'll be interesting to see how these younger candidates, if and how they invoke faith going forward. But for some communities, like Muslim Americans, that there might not be a big drop off particularly, right. And we're also kind of seeing, as we're already talking about 2028 candidates, thinking about the Democratic side, there's a lot of conversation around Jon Ossoff, for instance. Who did not make his Judaism a centerpiece of his re-election campaign for US Senate out of Georgia this go round, but may very well end up a talking point. And he's, I guess, mid millennial or maybe younger millennial. And so I'm real curious to see how he talks about his faith and how he intertwines that with his rhetoric if he were to end up pursuing a presidential run.
But in terms of whether or not these younger generations are going to embrace faith the same way that older generations are, I think that remains to be seen. Although there is, again, this discourse around some more conservative Christians in particular. And some conservative wings of Christianity suddenly seeing a surge of at least interest. I don't know if that's the same thing as actually showing up and being a part of those communities. But again, I'm curious what Tiffany has to say.
STANLEY: Yeah, I think the data is still out on some of those questions. I think anecdotally, we see bits of revival here and there for particular reasons. I reported on the Pew Research Survey last year. And for the first time, they noticed the religiosity is holding steady. So the trend line every 10 years, they do this huge survey. And religiously unaffiliated going up and religious folks have been going down. And now it's leveled off. But they were very clear. The researcher's like, hey, we don't really what this means, and we probably won't for a while. And younger people are still less religious than elders. So we are going to have to wait and watch what their behavior is as they age.
But I think one thing that I took away from writing that story was something that I think is interesting, where I think it's like 60 something percent of Americans identify as Christian, 29% identify as religiously unaffiliated. But it's in the 80% range. 83% believe in God. 86% think people have a soul or spirit. And so when we're talking about all these forces, I think it's interesting to note, there are a lot of people that don't feel at home in organized religion, but still believe in something. Because the rates of people that are very deliberately identify as atheist or agnostic or in the single digits. So there's a lot of room, I think, for people, if they're authentic about their faith, in politics. We were talking about this last week in a story that I helped edit, that our team did.
One of the data points that we saw was folks like Adam Hamilton and James Talarico and some of these folks in Iowa. I'm not sure how far our data went, but I know we at least had Texas, where it was like the religiously unaffiliated supported them in large numbers. And they were not turned off by the fact that James Talarico basically preaches a sermon on the stump a lot. And white evangelicals did not support them. So the idea that they were pandering to the evangelical vote, evangelicals were still like nope, Republican. So I think we can still look at all these messy categories. And I don't know if they'll change young people's mind. But we certainly saw that people that are not a part of organized religion were good with voting for folks that were authentic about why they were campaigning that way.
JENKINS: And I will just add a similar data point that I thought was fascinating, is that the religiously unaffiliated were in exit polling, which carries lots of caveats, I should say, were a larger percentage of the electorate than they have been in the past. And white evangelicals, while they had not moved politically much or at all, were a smaller section of the electorate. What that means is an open question. Whether that means religiously unaffiliated voted outside their traditional like margin, because that's always been a problem with the religiously unaffiliated, is they've often voted under the actual percentage that they occupy of the general politic, whereas white evangelicals have comparatively been disproportionately represented.
So we don't know if white evangelicals necessarily stayed home, although I certainly had some evangelical activists tell me concerns about that leading into the election. Or if it's, to Tiffany's point, if these were folks who, whether or not how they identify as a believer in someone who believes in a higher power or whether or not they even pray daily or attend a specific worship service, they don't seem turned off by a guy who, again, was citing scripture in his closing speech, like James Talarico.
SPROUSE: In our final few minutes together, I want to ask a question about meaning making. You’ve both talked about the importance, as religion reporters, of engaging honestly with people. How does your work help other people make meaning of their moments of celebration, their pain, their trauma—of their experiences? And then, on the flip side, how does what you do bring meaning to your own lives?
STANLEY: Yeah, I think I have a more nuanced view of this than I did when I graduated from HDS. I've talked about this other places, but I took a lot away from HDS in terms of pastoral care and how to be with people in really hard moments. And I interned for a year as a hospital chaplain and did all these things that HDS allowed me to do. And I've taken a lot of those lessons of how to listen empathically, reflectively try to reflect back what people are telling me so I'm getting it right. But there's a big difference, right, because I am taking your story and I am broadcasting it to the world. And I also want to make sure, this is not a counseling relationship. This is not private.
And I think now, I have learned that I need to give people a heads up of what it might look like to have your story broadcast to the world. I think I used to have this muckraking like, yes, we're going to share your story and shine a light. And that sometimes does make change. But I think all journalists, if we're being realistic, the times that we're able to tangibly see change happen is not always. Sometimes it's a rare thing. Sometimes there are policy changes or criminal actions or whatever based on our reporting. But a lot of times, it's inching along. And especially in religion, we report a lot on abuse victims. We report a lot on people that have suffered severe trauma.
And so I have, especially in the last few years being at AP, a billion people or something see AP content every day. That doesn't mean they all say mine, but ours goes out to thousands of news outlets. And I have found I need to prep people that, your photo will be all over the internet. Your story, your deepest, perhaps darkest thing is going to go a lot of places. Are you OK with that? And if you are not OK with that, I would rather not have a story. I, as a person with integrity, will walk away from the story if you are not 100% on board with this. Because I want to make sure that I'm not causing you further harm.
That's obviously different if it's a public figure, if it's a politician, if it's a media trained pastor. They don't get the same, I don't know, treatment that way. But when I'm talking to a vulnerable person. I think about some of my reporting the last couple of years. A refugee who's worried about their immigration status, somebody who is in the country illegally and hiding in their home or in the basement of a church. An abuse victim. I am going to make sure we can shield their identities in certain life threatening situations. But I want to make sure that they are really on board with it. And I think part of that comes out of my training with being in HDS of, I want to be a person in the world who tells stories. But I also know, sometimes it's not the right time for a story.
And I've had stories come back around where people are like, I'm not ready, I'm not ready, I'm not ready. Now I'm ready. And that, honestly, is when a story is like the most powerful, is somebody has agency and they are like, now I'm ready to tell this. And so I'm happy to sit on things and be patient and wait until it's the right time.
JENKINS: Yeah, I will second all of that. And just to commiserate. I mean, this is a thing I've talked to a lot of what I refer to as vulnerable sources, particularly in the last couple of years, but throughout my career. And that agency of it being their decision to tell the story, I found it sounds so simple, right? But it's not necessarily something that every journalist thinks about or is told to think about, even if it's obvious in the human interaction. But if a person, if you're saying, look, I want to be able to tell your story. If you don't-- offering that context, as Tiffany was talking about, about what happens when you write a story. What could potentially occur? Is this something you want to do?
And I have seen sources go through that process of being-- essentially making meaning of their story and what it will mean also for their lives on the other end. And be like, yeah, this is something I want to tell. This is something I want to put out there. And I mean, that's part of what trust actually is, right? Them both trusting you to tell their story. But you earning their trust by wanting to make clear to them, the stakes. And we can't always predict that for everybody. But what I found in my life, in the midst of doing all that, right. One is it's fascinating to watch stories that people consented to and what have you. How that affects them and affects communities. I don't control that. That's not my job as a journalist, but it is still fascinating to observe the way that journalism talks back to the communities that talked to the reporters.
And as a reporter, to answer the second part of your question, I mean, look, I get to go talk to the most incredible, fascinating people all over the world all the time, right. Just this year, I have been in speaking to major candidates and riding around in the back of a rickety car with a pastor who was tracing DHS agents. Right, these are different experiences, but they are places that I'm there to inform the readers and inform the public about why these are powerful religion stories. These are things I never would have been able to do if I was not a reporter, right. And so weighing that, the coolness of that, right, of being able to see all these things with the weight of responsibility. That, OK, you're there. But that is, then tell the story. And tell the truth and inform the public the best that you can. That has shaped me as well, right.
And I think being a witness to those kinds of events is a profound responsibility and privilege and should be taken as such. Even when it feels super cool, right. You should be reminded of what that responsibility actually means. Because if done poorly, it can have negative impacts to the people who have given you that trust to begin with.
SPROUSE: Thank you both, Tiffany and Jack. It's been a pleasure to talk with you. Thank you so much for joining today on the Meaning Makers of HDS.
STANLEY: Thank you.
JENKINS: Thank you so much for having me.
SPROUSE: Meaning Makers of HDS is presented by the Office of Communications at Harvard Divinity School. It is produced, hosted, and edited by me, Tyler Sprouse. Thank you for listening. Tune in next time for another episode of Meaning Makers of HDS.
Show notes:
Banner image and logo by Kristie Welsh
Intro/outro music: "Running On Home" by Joel Stewart, courtesy of Universal Production Music