Entwined Histories
Harvard Divinity School, the study of religion, and the American Revolution
The year 2026 marks the 250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence, and scholars across Harvard have been revisiting the people, ideas, and debates that shaped the nation’s founding. The American Revolution is often remembered through its political leaders and military campaigns. However, religion also played an important role in shaping how many early Americans understood the events unfolding around them—much like the intersections between religion and society today.
We Hold These Truths to Be Self-Evident
The signing of the Declaration of Independence in 1776 was a monumental occasion, affirming independence of the United States from Great Britain—espousing equality and the rights to “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” Yet these claims did not apply to all. Legalized slavery and discrimination on the basis of race, ethnicity, culture, class, and gender contradicted the ideals of our burgeoning nation. Throughout the fraught early years, religion was wielded as a weapon that caused grave harm, as well as a force for good in the name of freedom.
“The enslavement of people on the land now called the United States is not simply a story about race and racial oppression. It’s a story about religion and religious beliefs—religion formed the very scaffolding for racial myths and dominance,” says Marla F. Frederick, Dean of Harvard Divinity School. “Slaveholding religion was built on notions of superior and inferior peoples … and this version of Christian religion, according to Frederick Douglass, was ‘the climax of all misnomers, the boldest of all frauds.’”
Contrary to those who used religion to justify slavery, abolitionists and advocates for equality in the 1700s and 1800s worked in service of dignity and respect for all through social movements dedicated to emancipation, women’s liberation, education, and interreligious dialogue. Drawing a local connection to movements that would grow to transform the United States, Frederick explains, “These community leaders believed that we were all born in the imago Dei, the very image of God, and because of that we all had an inherent right to freedom. And much of their work—the work of people like Frederick Douglass, Lydia Maria Child, William Lloyd Garrison, John Brown, among many others—took place in Massachusetts.”
Additionally, Transcendentalists and Unitarians in the 1800s helped move society toward more openness and acceptance of different religious traditions, encouraging early Americans “to appreciate our shared humanity whether we worship at mosques, synagogues, temples, shrines, or churches—or whether we practice no particular religion at all,” says Frederick. She further clarifies, “The seeds of a liberating faith were never perfect seeds, but they invoked the ideals of freedom and equality that would allow people of all races, beliefs, and backgrounds to thrive. … Because that sense of reaching for our shared humanity is what holds this democratic experiment together.”
Calling upon the School’s vision, Frederick shares, “At Harvard Divinity School, we research and teach the varieties
of religion in service of a just world at peace across religious and cultural divides. And this vision is needed to truly live into the ideal vision cast by our founders—a declaration of freedom. Tending to a multiracial and multireligious democracy necessitates the education of scholars, scientists, lawyers, engineers, clerics, business and civic leaders, among others, who hold a deep and abiding respect for humanity at the center of their work.”
When asked for a historian’s perspective, David N. Hempton, Harvard University Distinguished Service Professor and Alonzo L. McDonald Family Professor of Evangelical Theological Studies, offers keen insights regarding the study of religion. “What one can say with certitude from a brief survey of an important educational experiment [multireligious education at HDS] is that the categories for studying religion have steadily expanded over the past two centuries,” he says. “As ever, students and the wider culture will help determine this evolution, and we will continue to explore how the concept of multifaith education has changed from encountering other traditions in order to missionize them, to learning about them out of curiosity, to learning from them out of epistemic humility, and, inexorably, to learning with them.” For Hempton, the vital work of HDS encompasses “reckoning genuinely with the past, using the present day to serve our mission faithfully, and being mindful of working toward a better future for all.”
To learn more about the evolution of religious studies at Harvard Divinity School, listen to Hempton’s address to the European Academy of Religion, “From Nonsectarian to Multifaith: An Educational Experiment in Religious Diversity at Harvard c. 1800–2020.”
As an anthropologist and scholar of religion, I have learned many lessons from my years of research and teaching, but they can all be summed up in one piercing and undeniable truth: We can wield religion to incite harm … or we can wield religion to inspire hope.
Founding Fathers Inspired by Education Focused on Ministry
Amid the broader study of religion and history, the Divinity School community holds a tangible connection to the founding of the country. As the U.S. marked its semiquincentennial earlier this year, the HDS Library team shared stories of treasured artifacts, including rare items associated with the American Revolution—books likely owned and signed by Founding Fathers John Hancock and Samuel Adams. These books represent the ideas and ideals cultivated at Harvard by the students and scholars who have inspired centuries of change. One vital element connecting the past, present, and future of education is the study of learned ministry.
Arguably the most famous signature in American history was discovered by chance in the Harvard Divinity School Library, a once-in-a-lifetime find that highlights the link between the Revolutionary period and the legacy of religious education at Harvard. For some time, rumors had circulated among the HDS Library team that the signature of John Hancock, the first signer of the Declaration of Independence and a 1754 graduate of Harvard College, was contained within one of the HDS Library’s many historical volumes. Searches for the elusive inscription proved unsuccessful, leading some to doubt the veracity of the claim.
“The signature became a legend on our team—a great story, but something we didn’t really believe existed,” says Nell Carlson, curator of historical collections at the HDS Library.
Then, in 2019 amid renovations to Swartz Hall, Carlson was working in one of HDS’s historical collections and happened to open to the cover page of Jonathan Mayhew’s 1763 Christian Sobriety: Being Eight Sermons on Titus 2:6, which Mayhew, also a Harvard graduate, preached to his congregation at Boston’s Old West Church. At the top of the browning page of the first-edition text was the signature of John Hancock; it has not yet been formally authenticated but, according to experts at Harvard Library, it closely resembles known examples of his handwriting.
The discovery of the John Hancock signature adds to HDS Library’s impressive collection of inscribed volumes and important texts dating back to the American Revolutionary period. The collection also features an eighteenth-century combined Book of Common Prayer and Bible belonging to Samuel Adams, another signer of the Declaration and Harvard College graduate. The volume, which Adams likely read as a Harvard student considering Christian ministry, contains his signature in the margins of numerous pages. For Carlson, artifacts like these help dissolve the distance between past and present, offering viewers added insight into the lives of significant figures.
“We can imagine Adams thinking about his future as he wrote his name in his Bible,” says Carlson. “We wonder, how did his faith change over the years that followed? How would his faith influence his life’s work?”
Along with texts linked to the Founding Fathers, the HDS Library maintains books of sermons preached at the time of the Revolution and an eighteenth-century book of hymns by Isaac Watts, which contains several instances of “denationalized” lyrics—Britain-oriented songs that have been reworded to reflect the revolutionary spirit of early Americans dating back to 1776.
These inscribed books and texts preserved in the HDS Library illustrate the importance of religious life and ministry while the idea and ideals of the United States were coming into clearer focus. Furthermore, these artifacts of the American Revolution offer a powerful reminder that Harvard, established in 1636 to promote preparation for religious learning and leadership, has served as an intellectual and physical home for the cause of freedom and independence since before the founding of the country. As we reflect on the country’s 250th anniversary and look toward Harvard’s quadricentennial, may we remember our entwined histories and protect the pledge of liberty and justice for all.
Samuel Adams, a key figure in the American Revolution, left his signature throughout a combined Book of Common Prayer and Bible. As a student at Harvard, Adams considered pursuing Christian ministry.
An example of a “denationalized” hymn dating back to the time of the American Revolution. The owner of this book of hymns by Isaac Watts reworked the lyrics to emphasize the revolutionary spirit of the 1700s. Here, the owner changed “O, Britain, praise thy mighty God, and make his Honours known abroad” to “The praises of thy mighty God, America shall sound abroad.”
We, as a country, are at a crossroads: war constantly humming, social and economic inequality threatening our social fabric, and advancements in technology offering benefits and threats far beyond our wildest imaginations. Today, perhaps more than ever, we must choose a more humane path—one that sees the imago Dei in each of us—to realize the ideals that inspired the founding of these United States.
Religion & the American Revolution
What was religious life like in America in 1776? In a recent episode of the Harvard Religion Beat podcast, Professor Catherine Brekus discusses the role of faith in the American Revolution, Harvard’s religious identity during the founding era, and why this history continues to inform conversations about religion, democracy, and public life.
“I think one thing that many Americans have forgotten is that the Revolution really did have a dramatic impact on religion in terms of the separation of church and state. Before the Revolution and the articles of the Constitution, this was not the case. . . . Christianity was a very important force in the Revolutionary years, but at the same time, the founders made it clear that they were committed to a republic in which people were free to practice their religion as they chose.”—Catherine Brekus, Charles Warren Professor of the History of Religion in America
The history of religion in early America is often pulled in two directions: some people emphasize the importance of Christianity in shaping the Revolution and the nation’s founding. Others focus on the constitutional protections that helped create one of the most religiously diverse societies in the world. As Brekus reminds us, both are aspects of the American story.
Understanding how they fit together can help us better understand some of the most enduring debates in American public life—and why they remain so relevant today.
Banner photo: Dean Marla F. Frederick delivers a TEDx Talk at GBH Studios on the history of religion and the founding of the United States.
Dean's Report
Learn more out about Harvard Divinity School’s recent research, teaching, and impact.